September 4


Why Positive Affirmations Don’t Work: Debunking the Myth of Self-Help Mantras

By Joshua Turner

September 4, 2023

Are you tired of reciting positive affirmations every day and not seeing any results? You’re not alone. These have become popular self-help tools in recent years, but many people have yet to be convinced of their effectiveness.

They are statements meant to help you overcome negative thoughts and beliefs. The idea is that by repeating them to yourself, you can change your mindset and improve your life. However, research has shown that they may not be as effective as we thought. In some cases, they can even make things worse.

So why don’t they work for everyone?

Understanding Positive Affirmations

Positive affirmations are repeated to oneself to promote positivity and self-belief. They are often used as a tool for personal development, with the belief that they can help to reprogram the subconscious mind and change negative thought patterns. However, despite their widespread popularity, more scientific evidence is needed to support their effectiveness.

While they may temporarily boost mood, they are unlikely to have a lasting impact on one’s mindset. These alone do not address the underlying psychological factors contributing to negative thoughts and beliefs.

Some studies suggest that affirmations are counterproductive, as they reinforce negative self-talk by highlighting the gap between one’s current and desired state.

Psychological science has shown that the subconscious mind helps in shaping our thoughts, beliefs, and behaviors. However, conscious thought or willpower does not easily influence the subconscious mind. To effect lasting change, address the underlying psychological patterns driving negative thought processes.

While they may temporarily boost mood, they are unlikely to have a lasting impact on one’s mindset. To effect lasting change, address the underlying psychological factors contributing to negative thoughts and beliefs.

Why Positive Affirmations May Not Work

Positive affirmations have been popularized to improve one’s mindset and achieve success. However, they may only sometimes work as intended. The reason for this is that they can conflict with reality. For example, if someone is struggling financially, repeating the affirmation “I am wealthy” may not be effective if their bank account says otherwise.

Negative thinking, thoughts, and beliefs can also hinder their effectiveness. If someone has a deeply ingrained negative idea about themselves, repeating a positive statement may not be enough to change their mindset. Also, if someone engages in negative self-talk, these affirmations may not be able to counteract the harmful effects of those thoughts.

In some cases, they can even backfire. If someone is struggling with anxiety, repeating the affirmation “I am calm” may actually increase their anxiety because it highlights the discrepancy between how they feel and how they want to feel.

These statements can be a helpful tool for improving mindset and achieving goals, but they may not always work as intended. Consider the role of reality, negative thinking, beliefs, self-talk, and the potential for backfiring when using them.

The Role of Self-Esteem

Self-esteem contributes to our mental and emotional well-being. People with low self-esteem often struggle with negative self-talk and self-doubt, making it difficult to believe in positive affirmations.


On the other hand, people with high self-esteem may find them unnecessary because they already have a strong sense of self-worth and confidence.

Confidence, closely related to self-esteem, can also impact their effectiveness. If someone lacks confidence in their ability to achieve their goals, these statements alone may not be enough to help them overcome their doubts and fears.

While these can benefit some people, they may not work for everyone, especially if self-esteem and confidence are underlying issues.

The Impact of Reality and Truth

Positive affirmations often encourage people to repeat unrealistic and untrue statements to themselves to manifest their desires. However, the impact of reality and truth cannot be ignored.

When we repeat statements that are not aligned with reality or truth, we run the risk of creating cognitive dissonance. Our minds are wired to seek consistency and coherence in our beliefs and actions. When our affirmations contradict reality and truth, our minds struggle to reconcile the two, leading to confusion and frustration.

Those not grounded in reality and truth can lead to a false sense of hope. While it’s necessary to maintain a positive outlook, it’s equally important to acknowledge the challenges and obstacles that we may face. When we ignore reality, we risk being ill-prepared to deal with these challenges, ultimately leading to disappointment and discouragement.

For these to be effective, they must be rooted in reality and truth. It means acknowledging the current state of affairs while also maintaining a positive outlook for the future. Doing so can create a sense of empowerment and motivation grounded in reality rather than wishful thinking.

The Power of Action and Commitment

Positive affirmations may not work because they focus on changing your thoughts without taking action. However, taking action is vital for achieving your goals. Without action, your goals will remain just dreams.

Commitment is also necessary for achieving your goals. You must commit to taking action consistently, even when it’s difficult or you don’t feel like it. Commitment means prioritizing your dreams and doing whatever it takes to achieve them.

When you take action and commit to your goals, you are more likely to see progress and feel motivated to continue. Effort and commitment create momentum, which can carry you through challenges and setbacks.

Projects and goals require action and commitment to be successful. It’s not enough to simply think positive thoughts or repeat affirmations. You must also take action and commit to your goals to see results.

The Influence of Beliefs and Mindset

Beliefs and mindset determine whether positive affirmations work. If you don’t believe in the statements you’re repeating, it’s unlikely that they will positively impact your life. Similarly, if you have a negative mindset, these validations may not be enough to overcome your negative thoughts.

Changing your beliefs and mindset takes time and effort. It’s something that takes time to be achieved. Positive statements can be a helpful tool in this process, but they’re not a magic solution. You need to be willing to work to change your beliefs and mindset if you want to see lasting results.


Success is also closely tied to beliefs and mindset. If you believe you can achieve your goals, you’re more likely to succeed. On the other hand, if you have limiting beliefs that hold you back, it’s unlikely that you’ll achieve the success you desire.

Optimism alone is not enough to change your beliefs and mindset. You need to take action to create real change in your life. It means identifying and challenging your limiting beliefs and developing a better perspective.

These can help change your beliefs and mindset, but they’re not a magic solution. To see lasting results, you must be willing to work to change your thoughts and philosophy.

The Effect of Stress and Anxiety

Stress and anxiety are common factors that can affect the effectiveness of positive affirmations. When stressed or anxious, our mind tends to be preoccupied with negative thoughts, making it difficult to focus on them. Instead, we may find ourselves dwelling on the negative aspects of our lives, which can reinforce negative beliefs and patterns of behavior.

Moreover, stress and anxiety can trigger the release of cortisol, a hormone that can harm our mental and physical health. High cortisol levels have been linked to depression, anxiety, and other mental health issues. Therefore, address the underlying causes of stress and anxiety before using these statements as a coping mechanism.

These statements may not effectively manage stress and anxiety if they are not tailored to the individual’s specific needs and circumstances. For example, if someone is experiencing financial stress, simply repeating statements about abundance may not be helpful. Instead, it may be more effective to focus on specific actions that can be taken to improve their financial situation.

While they can be a valuable tool for promoting positive thinking and self-esteem, they may not be effective for everyone, especially those dealing with high stress and anxiety levels. Address the underlying causes of negative thoughts and emotions before using them as a coping mechanism.

The Significance of Love and Compassion

Love and compassion are elements that positively impact our lives. When we show love and compassion towards ourselves, we develop a healthy self-image and increase our self-esteem. They help us deal with negative thoughts and emotions more effectively.

Self-compassion is vital in our everyday lives. It allows us to be kind to ourselves and to forgive ourselves for our mistakes. When we practice self-compassion, we develop a better outlook on life and are better equipped to handle stress and anxiety.

These elements also contribute to relationships with others. We create a positive environment that fosters growth and development when we show love and compassion towards those around us. These can lead to more fulfilling relationships and a greater sense of community.

The Interplay of Failures and Setbacks

One of the reasons positive affirmations may not work is that they can overlook the role of failures and setbacks in personal growth.

Failures and setbacks are an inevitable part of life and can provide valuable learning opportunities. When we experience a setback, trying to brush it off with a positive statement can be tempting. However, this can be counterproductive because it can prevent us from fully processing and learning from the experience.


Instead of immediately shifting our mindset to an optimistic one, take some time to reflect on what happened and what we can learn from the experience. Doing so can help us to develop resilience and a growth mindset, which is more effective than simply trying to think positively all the time.

Research has shown that people who can bounce back from failures and setbacks are more likely to achieve their goals in the long run. Embracing the challenges and setbacks that come our way can help us develop a sense of inner strength and confidence that can help us to overcome future obstacles.

The Role of Cognitive Psychology

Cognitive psychology helps in understanding why positive affirmations don’t work for everyone. Cognitive psychologists believe that our thoughts, emotions, and behaviors are interconnected and that changing our thoughts can lead to changes in our feelings and behaviors.

Cognitive psychotherapy, a therapy that focuses on changing negative thought patterns, effectively treats various mental health issues. However, these affirmatives alone may not change deeply ingrained negative thought patterns.

These may work for some people by temporarily improving their mood and confidence. Still, for others, they may be ineffective or even harmful if they lead to feelings of guilt or shame for not being able to think positively.

Cognitive psychology suggests that instead of repeating them, we must identify and challenge our negative thought patterns and replace them with more optimistic and realistic ones. This process takes time and effort but can lead to lasting change and improved mental health.

The Contribution of Positive Psychology

Positive psychology has made significant contributions to mental health. It emphasizes the importance of positive emotions, character strengths, and personal values in promoting happiness and life satisfaction.

Optimism, a key component of positive psychology, has been shown to have numerous benefits, including better physical health, stronger relationships, and increased resilience in the face of adversity. However, positive statements alone may not be enough to cultivate a lasting sense of optimism.

Happiness, another focus of positive psychology, is not just a fleeting emotion but a state of being. It involves a sense of purpose, meaningful relationships, and a healthy outlook on life. They may temporarily enhance the mood but do not address the underlying factors contributing to long-term happiness.

While these may have some benefits, they should not be relied upon as the sole method for improving mental health and welfare. Positive psychology offers a more comprehensive approach that emphasizes cultivating healthy emotions, character strengths, and personal values.

The Relevance of Self-Help and Motivation

Self-help and motivation have become buzzwords in recent years, with many people turning to books, courses, and seminars to improve their lives. While these resources can provide valuable insights and inspiration, they often fall short when it comes to creating lasting change.

Self-help books, in particular, have been criticized for oversimplifying complex issues and promoting a one-size-fits-all approach. The reality is that everyone’s situation is unique, and what works for one person may not work for another.


Motivation, on the other hand, is often seen as the key to success. While it’s true that motivation can help us get started on our goals, more is needed to sustain us over the long term. We also need discipline, focus, and a clear plan of action.

Real change requires a willingness to confront our fears and limitations and to take consistent action toward our goals.


In conclusion, positive affirmations alone are not enough to bring about significant changes in one’s life. While they may enhance our mood and motivation, they do not address the underlying issues that prevent us from achieving our goals. Life coaches and self-help gurus often tout them as a panacea for all our problems, but this is not true.

Instead of relying solely on them, we should focus on developing our values and strengths, practicing mindfulness, and using reality-based, neutral statements to reframe our thoughts and beliefs. Doing so can create a more balanced and grounded approach to personal growth and development.

Change takes time and effort, and no quick fixes or magic formulas exist. While they may be helpful in our growth journey, they should not be relied upon as the sole solution. A holistic approach to personal development can create lasting change and achieve our goals more sustainably and more fulfilling.

Frequently Asked Questions

Why do some people not see results from positive affirmations?

They only work for some because they are not a one-size-fits-all solution. Some people may not believe in the ones they are using, or they may not be using them consistently. Others may deal with deeper issues that require more than healthy thinking.

How can I ensure my positive affirmations are effective?

You need to believe in and repeat them to ensure they are effective. Use specific and actionable affirmations that align with your goals.Try to visualize your claims as if they have already come true.

What are some common mistakes people make when using positive affirmations?

Common mistakes people make when using them include using negative language, not being specific enough, and not believing in the affirmations they are using. Avoid using them as a replacement for action and effort.

Are there any scientific studies that prove the effectiveness of positive affirmations?

There have been some studies that suggest they can have a good impact on mental health. However, more research is needed to understand their effectiveness fully.

How do positive affirmations compare to other forms of self-improvement?

They can help in self-improvement, but they should not be the only tool used. Other forms of self-improvement, such as therapy, exercise, and meditation, can also positively impact mental health.

What can I do if positive affirmations are not working for me?

If they are not working for you, exploring other forms of self-improvement or seeking professional help may be helpful. Reassess them and ensure they align with your goals and values.

You might also like